Proportional Representation System

‘Illogical, Unprecedented &Unconstitutional’

By: Christian Conteh

The Leader of the Opposition in Parliament Hon. Chernor Maju Bah has called on His Excellency President Julius Maada Bio to reverse his directive to the Electoral Commission of Sierra Leone (ECSL)

This is in direct response to the commissions statement informing the public that President Bio has directed the institution to conduct next year’s multi-tier elections using the District Block and Proportional Representation (PR) system instead of the constituency- based elections, an action Hon Bah describes as a serious constitutional breach that will significantly reverse the gains the country has made in strengthening democracy in the post-war era.

“For the protection of the supremacy of our Constitution, I call on His Excellency the President, to reverse his directive to the ECSL. The primary right of the people of Sierra Leone to elect their Parliamentary representatives is through constituency- based elections, as enshrined in the Constitution,” Hon Bah states.

He acknowledged that the amendment of the Constitution then, which allows for such exercise of discretion by the President, was necessitated by the prevalence of a civil war in Sierra Leone, and the impossibility of establishing constituencies across the Country.

Adding that circumstances have since changed, with the country no longer at war, nor any part of the country inaccessible.

He emphasised that after the end of the civil war, the then President immediately reverted to the Constituency Based Elections system in 2007, as it promotes participation and democratic good governance.

“Constituencies already exist across the country, and we have held three successive successful general elections using the constitutionally prescribed Constituency system. It would therefore be illogical, unprecedented and unconstitutionalto revert to a PR system whose introduction was necessitated by the conditions of a raging war in the country,” he states. 

When this idea of using the PR system was initially introduced in Parliament in the Public Elections Bill 2022, it was heavily criticised and rejected by Members of Parliament. Members of the public, the civil society and the media also raised concern that the proposed PR system had the potential to limit the participation of citizens in the country’s democratic process. This led to its eventual withdrawal.

Hon Chernor Maju Bah expressed disappointment that after its rejection by Parliament, the executive would still give directives for the system to be imposed on the people of Sierra Leone. Adding that it is even more disturbing that such a change of the electoral system is being attempted on the eve of the multi-tier elections.

“Using the PR system in place of the constituency system would amount to taking away the rights of the people to choose their representatives directly and hand that power over to political parties,” he states.

While he acknowledges that the Constitution of Sierra Leone (Amendment) Act, 2001 Section 38A of the 1991 Constitution, grants ‘THE PRESIDENT discretionary powers to consult with the Electoral Commission and direct them, to conduct elections on the basis of the ‘EXISTING DISTRICTS’ in a manner to be known as the district block representation system instead of constituencies, the same amendment [Section 38A. (1)] specifies the condition precedent to the exercise of such discretion and directive:

S. 38A (1): –

“Where under any law for the time being in force, a date for a general election of Members of Parliament has been appointed but constituencies have not been established in accordance with subsection (3) of section 38 for the purposes of such election, …….”

Inarguably, Hon Bah points out that the condition precedent to the exercise of such Presidential discretion is non-existent.

“As it is, constituencies already exist and by Section 38 subsection (4) of the 1991 Constitution, the Electoral Commission SHALL only review such constituencies at intervals of NOT LESS THAN FIVE YEARS and NOT MORE THAN SEVEN YEARS. It is still less than five years since the present constituencies were established, taking into consideration Section 38 subsection (5) of the said Constitution:”

S. 38 (5)

“Where the boundaries of any constituency are altered in accordance with the provisions of this section, that alteration shall come into effect upon the next dissolution of Parliament, after the alteration has been approved by Parliament.”

The opposition leader further notes that these pronouncements by the Electoral Commission and its pandering to the whims and caprices of the Executive have the tendency to undermine the independence and credibility of the institution.

He ended by assuring the public that should they sense a desire to not reverse this decision, all legal remedies will be used to ensure that the rights of the people of Sierra Leone are not denied them, and that provisions of the Constitution are upheld.